"I have a mind like a steel... uh... thingy." Patrick Logan's weblog.

Search This Blog

Loading...

Monday, January 08, 2007

A Bigger Dork Than Me?

Update:

Uh, yeah. So I did read the press release. Maybe I missed something but it does appear to require Vista and it does not appear to support anyone else's system (MacOSX, Linux, etc.) So if you *like* the bundled mess that is the Microsoft product line, and your OS is running in the future (the same future that will run this server), then this product *might* be for you. If your hardware is old and your OS is older than the future, or from a non-Microsoft OS vendor, then you appear to be out of luck. Unless you wish to upgrade every thing you own. Then by all means.

So here is what you do... go down to Best Buy. Tell them you want a network storage device and a print server, all in one. Tell them you want a redundant disk. They probably have several brands. If you have another reasonably good electronics store in town, they probably have another one or two brands to choose from. Buy one today, and it will continue to work with everything you have today. Just don't upgrade to Microsoft's Digital Decade OS of the Future. That one will almost *certainly* not work with anything else you already have in your house.

Bill sucks. Microsoft has no clue. This "Digital Decade" (how catchy!) we are in happens to run on the *internets*. They are a series of *tubes*. They are *independent* of your specific operating system. Especially if they are of the future of which Microsoft wishes to bind you to.

End Update

And that's saying something. A part of Bill Gates' so called "Digital Decade" is to someday release a "Windows Home Server" for "less than $500"...

If you have multiple PCs, then you want files that are available all the time no matter which PCs are turned on or off, and you'd also like to have a server that, when you just add storage, it automatically takes advantage of that. You don't have to think about drive names or moving files around.

In fact, you get redundancy, so even if you have physical failures you have recoverability... We think it is a real leadership product. Homes with multiple PCs will find it very attractive.

Guess what, Bill? You need to get out more, even if it is just down to the local Best Buy store.

For some time now I have had a network storage "server" running at home. It plugs into the network and just works. You can add as much storage as you want as larger disks become cheaper.

I plugged another USB drive into one of its USB slots. The box knew by default to use this drive as redundant storage. We use the network drive for common storage (across Windows 2000, Windows XP, Linux, and MacOSX) as well as for backup storage for each of those other machines. The USB drive backs up the common storage and backs up the backups.

Did I mention this "home server" also has a network print server? Yes, just plug in a printer's USB cable to another of the server's USB slots. I hope Bill's print server is as easy to setup (for MacOSX and Linux as well as all the Windows) whenever it arrives in Best Buy.

This setup came in many months ago at less than half the $500 target of Bill's. OK, I had a USB drive anyway I could use as the redundant storage. So purchasing that brings the sum into Bill's neighborhood *today*.

Will Bill's system work as well across all these other systems? Will it even work with Bill's own obsolete Windows 2000?

One more thing... this server of mine happens to run Linux and Samba (I know that because I am a geek and a dork, but no one needs to know that.)

Well, people with these servers may eventually find out once they bring Vista into their homes and Vista refuses (apparently?) to work with the Samba software. One more reason Vista will never see the inside of my house.

One more quote, but from Microsoft Watch...

The product will open up new sales and services opportunities for the channel. Many consumers can't properly configure a Wi-Fi router now. It's unrealistic that many could set up a server without some assistance.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeroconf?

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi,
can you be more specific about this server?
Brand, operating system etc?
Thanks

Ορέστης said...

I'm one of the stupid consumers :)

I've heard of these things, but never sat down to learn how they work. Care to post a link ?

New Jersey Asshat said...

Ummm, maybe you could find out a little about the product [other than picking apart Gates quotes?] before you dismiss it?

May I suggest this?
http://on10.net/Blogs/jesse/windows-home-server-will-live-in-your-closet-simplify-your-life/

New Jersey Asshat said...

Oh and this too:
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20070108-8573.html

Patrick Logan said...

Yeah, so sorry. I just read the press release. This thing apparently *does* require Vista.

So this is just another part of the bundled mess that is the Microsoft product line. Maybe good for the Microsoft crowd, but Vista is not coming near my house.

New Jersey Asshat said...

No, it doesn't require Vista. The demos showed a Vista client but this should be WinXP and possibly Win2000 compatible.

Sometimes you sound like one of the anti-MS trolls on /.

Patrick Logan said...

"Sometimes you sound like one of the anti-MS trolls on /."

I don't disagree. I have such high hopes for MSFT and yet they continue to disappoint me. Any large corp will to a degree, yet...

OTOH, how can I be a troll when this is *my* blog???

Anyway, I often write half-thoughts to see who corrects me.

No one has said it supports MacOSX or Llinux yet though. And I bet Win2000 will be off the table. I also bet WinXP will not be as full-fledged as Vista. We'll see.

Thanks -- if you are a reader you are expected to keep my ignorance in check. That's what.

Blog Archive

About Me

Portland, Oregon, United States
I'm usually writing from my favorite location on the planet, the pacific northwest of the u.s. I write for myself only and unless otherwise specified my posts here should not be taken as representing an official position of my employer. Contact me at my gee mail account, username patrickdlogan.